Lil Travel Folks is supported by its readers. If you purchase through a link on my site, I may earn a commission. Learn more

Sharing is caring!

Hey there, fellow pizza lovers! Our family is always on the hunt for the best pizza in Hendersonville, TN, about 30 minutes from our home.

variety of pizzas on table with different toppings, aerial view

We’ve made it our mission to try out all the delicious pizza places in the area, and boy, do we have some amazing finds to share with you! Whether you’re craving a crispy crust, authentic Italian food, or a variety of pizza options to satisfy everyone’s taste buds, we’ve got you covered.

From the friendly staff and fast service at well-known spots like Papa John’s and Pizza Hut, to the hidden gems like Brixx and NY Pie, we’ve tasted our way through the pizza scene on Indian Lake Blvd, W Main St, and even East Nashville!

And let’s not forget about our all-time favorite pizza places, where the signature sauce and fresh toppings truly make for a mouthwatering experience.

Join us as we share our discoveries of the best pizza restaurants in Hendersonville, TN, where great food, great service, and good times await! Stay tuned for some fantastic recommendations, menu items, and even some delicious dessert pizza. The whole family is sure to find something they love, so let’s dive in!

NY Pie: Authentic New York Style Pizza in Hendersonville’s Backyard

Craving that perfect slice of thin crust pizza in Hendersonville, TN? Look no further than NY Pie! This authentic New York style pizzeria takes pride in crafting its delicious pizza using fresh homemade dough, prepared from scratch daily. No frozen dough here, folks! The talented team members at NY Pie skillfully hand-toss the dough into a thin, even crust, ensuring a mouthwatering, crispy texture in every bite.

What sets NY Pie apart is their dedication to quality. Their brick ovens ensure that each pizza is cooked to perfection, with no conveyor belt ovens or screens in sight. The fresh sauce is made daily from imported Italian tomatoes, bringing that classic taste we all know and love. And let’s not forget the cheese – NY Pie exclusively uses Grande Cheese Company products, known for their all-natural ingredients and top-of-the-line quality.

NY Pie brings the authentic flavors of New York and New Jersey to Hendersonville, drawing on their Northeastern roots and passion for great pizza. With their fresh ingredients and commitment to excellence, it’s no wonder NY Pie has become one of our favorite pizza places in town. Don’t miss out on this delicious slice of the Big Apple right here in Hendersonville!

On the Menu:

At NY Pie, you’ll find a wide array of mouthwatering options:

  • Appetizers: Garlic Knots, Cheese Sticks, Fried Calamari, Mozzarella Sticks and more
  • Salads: Antipasto, Caesar, Chicken, Garden, Greek
  • Hand-tossed Pizzas such as NY cheese, NY special, meatball pie, margarita, sriracha chicken and more.
  • Pan Pizzas like Grandma’s Pie and Sicilian
  • Desserts:
  • Cannolis
  • NY Cheesecake
  • Tiramisu
  • Drinks such as fountain sodas, iced tea, juice boxes and the Hendersonville location carries White Claw and beer

Our Recommendations:

For a truly unique and memorable experience at NY Pie, try some of their specialty pizzas that set them apart from the rest:

  1. Meatball Pie – Featuring meatballs, fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil, and shredded parmesan on a marinara base.
  2. Greek – A delightful combination of spinach, tomatoes, black olives, red onions, minced garlic, Feta, and Mozzarella cheeses on an extra virgin olive oil base.
  3. Garlic Chicken – Marinated garlic chicken and spinach with Swiss and Mozzarella cheeses on an extra virgin olive oil base.
  4. Sriracha Chicken – A spicy twist with BBQ chicken and bacon, topped with Mozzarella cheese on a ranch/Sriracha base.

Don’t forget to try their delicious dessert options, like the classic NY Cheesecake or the indulgent Tiramisu.

Location: 305 Indian Lake Blvd, Hendersonville

Learn more about NY Pie and see the full menu here

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza: Discover the Art of Wood-Fired Flavor

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza offers a warm, inviting atmosphere for friends and families to connect and enjoy life’s moments. With a focus on scratch-made, wood-fired fare, Brixx combines creative and globally-inspired flavors with comforting favorites. Hand-pulled mozzarella, handmade dough, and hand-picked herbs contribute to the authentic taste, while locally sourced wood enhances the smoky flavor of their signature brick ovens.

Committed to inclusivity, Brixx provides vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, including vegan cheese at no extra charge and 100% vegan traditional dough. Their dedication to fresh ingredients, global flavors, and accommodating dietary needs makes Brixx a go-to spot for delicious pizza and beer in a casual, welcoming environment.

On the Menu:

  • Variety of pizzas: Brixx Classics, Veggie Lovers
  • Starters: Spinach and Artichoke Dip, Hummus Trio, Brixx Stixx, Bruschetta, Wings
  • Salads: Spinach, Mediterranean, Arugula and Pear, Southwestern Chicken, Thai Chicken
  • Desserts: Root Beer Float, Chocolate Chunk Cookie Pie
  • Drinks: Coca Cola products, Cocktails, Large variety of beer on tap

Our recommendations:

  1. Spicy Shrimp Pizza: Calabrian chili pepper shrimp, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, goat cheese, and fresh basil
  2. Sweet Thai Chicken Pizza: Wood-roasted chicken in sweet chili sauce, goat cheese, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pistachios, and Thai peanut satay sauce
  3. Wild Mushroom Pizza: Wood-roasted shiitake, portobello, button mushrooms, mozzarella, olive oil base, arugula, and shaved parmesan
  4. Pear & Gorgonzola Pizza: Sliced pears, mozzarella, gorgonzola, walnuts, and caramelized onions on an olive oil base
  5. Hummus Trio with Wood Fired Pita Chips: A delicious starter to share
  6. Arugula and Pear Salad: A fresh and unique salad option
  7. Chocolate Chunk Cookie Pie: A must-try dessert for chocolate lovers

Location: 300 Indian Lake Blvd, Hendersonville

Learn more about Brixx and see the full menu here

Sanders Ferry Pizza & Pub: A Hendersonville Hidden Gem for Pizza Lovers

Sanders Ferry Pizza & Pub is one of our favorite pizza places in Hendersonville, TN, and for good reason! With their friendly staff and great service, this local pizzeria goes above and beyond to make each visit memorable. It’s no wonder their customers are so pleased with the experience.

When it comes to their menu, Sanders Ferry Pizza offers an impressive variety of over 15 delicious specialty pizzas. From classic options like the Margherita and meatball pies to their creatively-named Veggimus Maximus (loaded with spinach, banana peppers, artichokes, jalapenos, and more), there’s something to suit every taste bud. Don’t miss their mouthwatering hot chicken & waffles pizza for a truly unique flavor experience!

In addition to their fantastic pizza selection, Sanders Ferry Pizza also serves up a variety of tasty snacks, wings, toasty sandwiches, salads, and their LHP Pockets – a scrumptious take on stuffed sandwiches. And when it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth, their dessert options won’t disappoint.

The next time you’re in Hendersonville, make sure to stop by Sanders Ferry Pizza & Pub for some great food and a good time. Whether you’re dining in with their attentive staff or ordering takeout via the Slice app, you’re in for a treat!

On the Menu:

Sanders Ferry Pizza & Pub offers an extensive menu that caters to different tastes. Some of the items they serve include:

  • Specialty Pizzas (e.g., Cheesin’, Buffalo Soldier, Sanders Ferry Supreme, and Veggimus Maximus)
  • Snacks (e.g., Sanders Sticks, Spinach Bomb, Cheesy Bread, and Tots)
  • Totchos (e.g., Original Totcho, Philly Cheesesteak Totcho, and The Animal Totcho)
  • Sanders Salads (e.g., Nashville Hot Chicken Salad, Chef’s Creation Salad, and Five-O Salad)
  • Wings & Tenders (e.g., Wings and Baked Tenders with Fries)
  • LHP Pockets (e.g., Buffalo Chicken Pockets, Grilled Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pockets, and Artichoke, Spinach & Feta Pockets)
  • Toasty Sammiches (e.g., The Bill Sammich, The Italian Stallion Sammich, and BBQ Sammy Sammich)
  • Sweet Snacks (e.g., Sugar Sticks, S’mores Dessert Pizza, and Chocolate Chip Cannoli)
  • Beverages (e.g., 2 Liter, Unsweetened Tea, 20 oz. Coke, and Bottled Water)

Our Recommendations:

For a unique and delightful dining experience, we recommend trying the following items from Sanders Ferry Pizza & Pub’s menu:

  1. Hot Chicken & Waffles Pizza: A creative combination of Nashville hot chicken, butter base, crispy waffles, bacon, egg, and a maple syrup drizzle.
  2. Gone Hog Wild Pizza: This pizza features slow-smoked BBQ, bacon, onions, cheese, pickles, coleslaw, and a honey jalapeno BBQ sauce.
  3. Philly Cheesesteak Totcho: A twist on the classic totchos, topped with steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, creamy horseradish drizzle, and cheese.
  4. Five-O Salad: A refreshing salad with crushed pineapple, diced ham, banana peppers, feta cheese, and honey vinaigrette dressing.
  5. Nashville Hot Chicken Pockets: These LHP Pockets are filled with breaded chicken, pizza sauce, cheese, pickles, and ranch.
  6. The Great Hambino Sammich: A satisfying sandwich with basil pesto Alfredo, mozzarella cheese, ham, mushrooms, and tomatoes.
  7. S’mores Dessert Pizza: Indulge your sweet tooth with this dessert pizza featuring the classic flavors of s’mores.

Location: 125 Sanders Ferry Rd, Hendersonville

Learn more about Sanders Ferry and see the full menu here

Jolly Ollie’s Pizza & Pub: A Family and Pet-Friendly Haven in Hendersonville

As a family that frequently visits Hendersonville, we absolutely love dining at Jolly Ollie’s Pizza & Pub. They have a strong belief in making pizza special, and it shows in the quality of their food and the friendly atmosphere they create. Being a local establishment, Jolly Ollie’s is truly dedicated to supporting the community and the men and women in uniform. Their commitment to giving back is evident in everything they do.

With over 10 years of experience, Jolly Ollie’s consistently delivers delicious and unique meals with a smile. Their prompt service ensures that we can enjoy our food without any long waits. And as pet lovers, we truly appreciate that Jolly Ollie’s is a dog-friendly restaurant. It’s such a relief to know that we can bring our furry family members along and have a great dining experience together.

In short, Jolly Ollie’s Pizza & Pub has become a go-to spot for our family whenever we’re in Hendersonville. Their exceptional food, warm atmosphere, and community spirit keep us coming back for more. (Plus they have a great selection of kid’s meals!! Important to our family of six!)

On the Menu:

  • Appetizers: Wings, Garlic Cheese Loaf, Poppers, and more
  • Salads: House, Greek, Chef’s, Caesar
  • Pizzas: Customizable and specialty options
  • Pastas: Spaghetti, Baked Ziti, Chicken Alfredo, and more
  • Grinders: Variety of meat and veggie options
  • Desserts: Tiramisu, NY Cheesecake, Cookies
  • Kids Menu: Spaghetti, Alfredo, Pizza, Fish & Chips, Chicken Tenders

Our Recommendations:

  1. Ollie’s Supreme Pizza: A signature favorite
  2. Green Island Pizza: Unique vegetarian option
  3. Chicken Florentine Pizza: A tasty, gourmet choice
  4. Spicy Garlic Shrimp Scampi Pasta: A flavorful seafood dish
  5. Philly Steak Grinder: Classic sandwich with a twist

Location: 82 New Shackle Island Rd, Hendersonville

Learn more about Jolly Ollie’s and see the menu here

Runners Up

These are our favorite, unique pizza places in the area. Here are some honorable mentions:

  1. Roma Pizza and Pasta
  2. Fox’s Pizza Den
  3. Gondola House

And, of course you have your chain pizza places such as Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns Pizza, Domino’s, Jet’s Pizza and more. There is no shortage of pizza in the Hendersonville, TN area! If you live nearby and are looking for something new, or you have a place to stay in the area, many of these places offer pizza delivery, too. You can also order from the local Papa Murphy’s if you have a place to cook a fresh pizza.

Final Thoughts on the Best Pizza in Hendersonville

Today, we’ve explored the top pizza destinations in Hendersonville, each offering a unique and delicious experience. From NY Pie’s classic hand-tossed pizzas to Jolly Ollie’s inviting pub atmosphere, and finally Brixx Wood Fired Pizza’s globally inspired flavors, there’s a perfect option for every pizza lover. So, gather your friends and family and indulge in some mouthwatering pizza at these exceptional spots in Hendersonville.

Similar Posts