The Best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge (2022)

Looking for an Italian restaurant in the Smoky Mountain area? Check out our guide to the best Italian restaurants in Pigeon Forge to find one near you.

collage of various photo of delicious italian pasta dishes

If you’re looking for a delicious and authentic Italian meal while in the town of Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, then look no further than the many Italian restaurants that are scattered throughout the area.

From classic pasta dishes to mouth-watering pizzas, these establishments will have you feeling like you’re right in Italy! Here is a list of some of the best Italian restaurants in Pigeon Forge and the surrounding areas.

Types of Italian cuisine that can be found in the area

Three of the most popular Italian restaurants in the Pigeon Forge area are Johnny Carino’s, Red Tomato Bistro, and Ristorante DellaSantina. All three of these establishments offer some form of pasta dishes on their menu.

From classic spaghetti with marinara sauce to penne with tomato cream sauce to tortellini with marinara sauce, Olive Garden has an extensive list of fresh pastas that will leave your taste buds singing!

More than just pastas, you’ll find pizzas, calzones, subs and sandwiches at the Red Tomato Bistro; while at Ristorante DellaSantina you can indulge in chicken parmesan, lasagna or spaghetti and meatballs.

So if you are craving marinara sauce or even spicy marinara sauce, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella or other Italian favorites, we’ve got you covered.

Best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

**Hours are current as of January 2022. Check with the restaurant to ensure they are open and have what you want before heading out.

Johnny Carino’s

Famous for…

Handcrafted pizzas, fresh salads, classic Italian dishes including a create your own pasta, signature sips cocktails and frozen drinks, handcrafted desserts.

Location

2425 Parkway, Pigeon Forge

Hours

11AM-9PM Sunday-Thursday, 11AM-10PM Friday & Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

J Del’s Pizza

Famous for…

New York hand-tossed pizzas, garlic knots, cheese pizza by the slice, salads, hot and cold subs, calzones and classic Italian dishes such as baked ziti, lasagna, penne, linguini and ravioli as well as authentic New York cheesecake.

Location

2664 Teaster Lane #104 A, Pigeon Forge

Hours

Closed on Sunday, 4-10PM Monday-Thursday, 4-11PM Friday & Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Big Daddys Pizzeria

There are two other locations in the area as well: Gatlinburg and Sevierville

Famous for…

Wood-fired brick oven pizzas, wood-fired roasted wings, dough daddies, salads, sandwiches and desserts.

Location

3053 Parkway, Pigeon Forge

Hours

11AM-9PM every day of the week except Wednesdays, when they are closed

Website/Menu

_________________

Mellow Mushroom

This restaurant is at the Island in Pigeon Forge with a great location for seeing all the happenings at the Island.

Famous for…

Distinctive stone-baked dough made with Appalachian spring water. Mellow Mushroom also serves munchies, salads, sandwiches, and burgers in addition to stone-baked pizzas. Pick from a variety of 24 draft beers or sip on a custom cocktail of your choosing. Many of the pizzas can be made gluten-free or vegan.

Location

131 Island Drive, Suite 3101, Pigeon Forge

Hours

Open every day of the week from 11AM to 10PM.

Website/Menu

_________________

Best Italian Restaurants Near Pigeon Forge in the Great Smoky Mountains

Best Italian – Cafe & Pizzeria

Famous for…

New York-style Italian eats such as pizza, signature garlic rolls made fresh daily, classic Italian dishes such as spaghetti, lasagna, dishes with poultry, beef and seafood, and an extensive kid’s menu.

Location

968 Parkway Suite 9, Gatlinburg and an express location at 710 Parkway, Gatlinburg

Hours

11AM-9PM Sunday-Thursday, 11AM-10PM Friday & Saturday for both locations

Website/Menu

_________________

Gondolier Italian Restaurant

Famous for…

Variety of pizza including gluten free, both traditional and white pizzas, a ton of appetizer options, salads, classic Italian pasta dishes such as linguini, fettucini, Gondolier spaghetti and lots more plus specialties like manicotti and lobster ravioli. Most extensive Italian menu in the area.

Location

964 Dolly Parton Pkwy #3707, Sevierville

Hours

11AM-10PM Sunday-Thursday, 11AM-9:30PM Friday, 11AM-11PM Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Red Tomato Bistro

Famous for…

Specialty pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, traditional Italian dishes such as baked manicotti, spaghetti and eggplant parmesan, burgers and salads.

Location

248 Collier Drive, Sevierville

Hours

Website/Menu

_________________

Ristorante DellaSantina

Famous For…

Fresh seafood flown in 3 times a week, 21 day dry aged filet mignon, freshly sliced antipasto plates, daily made tiramisu.

Very highly rated on Yelp with over 40 5-star reviews! People rave about the quality and authenticity of the food, large portions and friendly service.

Location

2004 Red Bank Rd, Sevierville

Hours

Closed Sunday and Monday, 3-9PM Tuesday-Thursday, 3-10PM Friday-Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Taste of Italy

Famous for…

Gourmet pizzas, subs, calzones, traditional Italian dishes such as picatta and marsala (various kinds), salads and a very large pasta menu.

Location

1235 East Parkway, Gatlinburg

Hours

Closed Sunday and Monday, 11:30AM-9PM Tuesday-Friday, 11:30AM-8PM Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Olive Garden

Famous for…

Casual dining atmosphere with unlimited salad and breadsticks. The Tour of Italy combination plate with three Italian favorites. Cocktails and desserts.

Location

1570 Parkway, Sevierville

Hours

11AM-10PM Sunday-Thursday, 11AM-11PM Friday & Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Nino’s Pizzeria & Eatery

Famous for…

Specialty pizzas, subs, calzones, stromboli, baked ravioli, fettucini, shrimp scampi and many other traditional Italian dishes.

Location

105 Long Springs Road, Sevierville

Hours

Closed Sunday, 11AM-8PM Monday-Thursday, 11AM-9PM Friday-Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Papa Leone’s Pizzeria

Famous for…

Specialty Pizzas: Philly Cheesesteak, Buffalo Chicken, Bbq Chicken and Lasagna Pizza. Also for Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza and a special pizza called the Sasquatch. They also do subs, calzones, salads and appetizers.

Location

1440 Upper Middle Creek Rd #207, Sevierville

Hours

2-9PM Sunday, Closed Monday, 3-9PM Tuesday-Thursday, 3-10PM Friday-Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Stonehouse Pizza

Famous for…

Homemade dough fresh made daily with super fresh ingredients. They have a full line of Pizza, Subs, Salads and other good stuff! They also bake and make fresh deserts daily. Family owned business.

Location

1725 Waldens Creek Rd #101, Sevierville

Hours

Closed Sunday, 11AM-9PM Monday-Thursday, 11AM-10PM Friday-Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Luigi’s Pizzeria

Famous for…

Specialty Pizza such as Stuffed Crust Meat Lover’s, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Lasagna Pizza and Chicken Parmigiana Pizza. Also wings, pasta, salads, stromboli and calzones.

Location

1017 Parkway, Gatlinburg

Hours

3-11PM Sunday-Thursday, 3PM-12AM Friday-Saturday

Website/Menu

_________________

Tips for finding good food deals at Italian restaurants

When it comes to finding good food deals at Italian restaurants, there are a few things that you can do. One of the best tips is to look for restaurants that offer lunch specials. Many Italian restaurants offer great discounts on food items during their lunch hour.

You can also find good deals by ordering food to go. Many Italian restaurants offer significant discounts on their food when you take it home with you, plus you won’t have to pay a tip. Finally, be sure to ask about special deals and promotions that may be available at the time of your visit.

Conclusion

Whether you are looking for some amazing pizza or authentic Italian fare, you’re sure to find what you are looking for at one of these great restaurants on our list of Best Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge.

If you’re willing to drive to the neighboring towns of Gatlinburg or Sevierville you open up a lot of other options. So be sure to stop by one of these amazing restaurants while you are in town or check out fine dining nearby!