Lil Travel Folks is supported by its readers. If you purchase through a link on my site, I may earn a commission. Learn more
As a mom of four lively boys, I’ve found that the restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge offer a delightful mix of convenience, variety, and fun that keeps the whole family happy. The Island is not just a collection of eateries; it’s a vibrant entertainment complex where the dining options play a starring role.
From the moment we step onto the Island, we’re greeted with the enticing aromas of some of the best restaurants in Pigeon Forge. Whether it’s the smell of fresh pizza dough being tossed at Mellow Mushroom, the hearty, home-cooked scents wafting from Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen, or the smoky allure of Timberwood Grill, there’s something to tickle everyone’s taste buds.
And it’s not just about the food. The Island is a great place for a family outing, with retail stores, rides, games, and live music to enjoy. Plus, with many hotels within easy walking distance, it’s the perfect place for a Smoky Mountain vacation. So, join me as I share our family’s favorite dining spots and some of the most popular restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge.
The Island Dining Experience
Located on the Island Drive, the Island in Pigeon Forge is not just a collection of restaurants; it’s an entertainment complex that offers a variety of attractions for the whole family. From the retail stores to the live music on the concert stage, there’s always something to do and see. It’s a place where you can have a good time, whether you’re dining, shopping, or just taking in the sights.
One of the most popular attractions is the Great Smoky Mountain Wheel. This towering Ferris wheel offers breathtaking views of the Smoky Mountains and the surrounding area. It’s a must-see attraction that adds a bit of thrill to your dining experience.
The Island Show Fountain is another feature that enhances the dining experience at The Island. This state-of-the-art fountain puts on a mesmerizing show of water, light, and sound that you can enjoy from the tiered seating areas around the fountain. It’s a spectacle that adds a bit of magic to your visit.
The Island in Pigeon Forge offers a variety of dining areas, from the laid-back atmosphere of Jimmy Buffett’s Margaritaville to the lodge-themed restaurant, Timberwood Grill. Whether you’re looking for a place to enjoy a hearty meal of classic southern comfort food or a spot to relax with a delicious seafood dish, you’ll find the perfect spot at The Island.
Now, let’s take a look at the places to eat at The Island, broken down into snacks, sweets, drinks and full service restaurants.
Best Snack Stands and Quick Bites
Auntie Anne’s at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a haven for pretzel lovers. Known for their “little rewards,” Auntie Anne’s offers freshly baked pretzels all day long in a variety of flavors. The light, bread-like texture and the sweet taste of their pretzels make for a perfect snack while exploring the Island.
Their menu is diverse, with options like Original, Cinnamon Sugar, Sweet Almond, Honey Whole Grain, Sour Cream and Onion, and Garlic Pretzels. They also offer Stix and the Pretzel Dog for those looking for a hearty bite. If you prefer bite-sized treats, their most popular pretzel flavors are available as Pretzel Nuggets.
What sets Auntie Anne’s apart is their Perfect Guarantee: if you don’t love your pretzel, they’ll replace it with one that you do. This commitment to customer satisfaction makes Auntie Anne’s a great option for a quick bite at The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Kapop! Gourmet Popcorn
Kapop! Gourmet Popcorn at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a popcorn lover’s dream. This isn’t your ordinary movie theatre popcorn; Kapop! offers 14 flavors of the freshest homemade popcorn served by their friendly staff.
From classic favorites like Caramel Corn and Kettle Corn to unique flavors like Dill Pickle, Bacon, and even Cheeseburger, Kapop! has a flavor for every palate. They also offer fun snacks, making it a great place for a quick bite while exploring the Island.
Kapop! Gourmet Popcorn provides four different size options: their standard box, a refillable bucket, 3-gallon sports tins, and pre-packaged gift cylinders. This makes it easy to choose the right amount for your family or to take home as a delicious reminder of your visit.
While they don’t typically ship orders, exceptions can be made for orders of $50 or higher. So, if you can’t make it to the Island or want to enjoy their delicious popcorn from the comfort of your home, you can call to ask about inventory and place an order.
Visiting Kapop! Gourmet Popcorn is a fun and tasty experience that adds a little extra pop to your visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Yee Haw Snack Shack
Yee Haw Snack Shack at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a delightful spot for quick bites with big flavor. This charming snack shack serves authentic New Orleans Snowballs with over 100 flavor combinations and toppings, making it a fun and refreshing stop during your visit to The Island.
But the Yee Haw Snack Shack offers more than just snowballs. They also serve up 100% Angus Beef Hot Dogs, Chili Dogs, Nachos, Funnel Cake Fries, Fountain Sodas, Frozen Lemonade, and Rootbeer Floats. It’s a place where you can enjoy a quick, tasty snack while taking in the sights and sounds of The Island.
Located at the base of the Great Smoky Mountain Wheel, the Yee Haw Snack Shack is open seven days a week to serve you. It’s even been voted the best Snowballs in town! So, on your next visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge, make sure to stop by the Yee Haw Snack Shack for a flavorful and fun snack experience.
Best Sweets and Dessert Options
Big Rocky Candy Kitchen
Big Rocky Candy Kitchen is a sweet lover’s paradise at The Island in Pigeon Forge. This delightful candy store offers a wide array of homemade sweets and treats made from scratch. From saltwater taffy and creamy fudge to crisp caramel apples, gourmet popcorn, and gelato, there’s something to satisfy every sweet tooth.
One of the best things about Big Rocky Candy Kitchen is the friendly staff who are always ready to help you find the perfect treat. And if you’re unsure about what to choose, they offer free samples to help you decide.
Visiting Big Rocky Candy Kitchen is not just about buying candy; it’s about experiencing the joy and nostalgia that comes with a traditional candy store. It’s a great place for the whole family to enjoy and one of our favorite stops during our visits to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Byrd’s Famous Cookies
Byrd’s Famous Cookies at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a delightful stop for cookie lovers. With a rich history dating back to 1924, Byrd’s has been baking memories using the same style and recipes handed down from their founders.
When you step into Byrd’s Famous Cookies, you’re invited to try all their cookie flavors. They have a Cookie Bar where you can sample your favorite flavors for free, and maybe even discover a new one. Their variety of sweet treats and specialty pantry items make for a perfect snack during your visit or a lovely gift to take home.
The Cookie Crew at Byrd’s Famous Cookies is always ready to help, making your visit a warm and welcoming experience. And the best part? They offer free samples all day, every day!
Visiting Byrd’s Famous Cookies is more than just a trip to a cookie store; it’s a journey into a long-standing tradition of baking excellence. It’s a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth visiting The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Cinnabon at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a sweet retreat for those who believe that life needs frosting. When you hear the name “Cinnabon,” you can’t help but think of their ooey, gooey cinnamon rolls that are a delight to the senses. But that’s not all they offer. Cinnabon also serves refreshing, flavorful beverages that perfectly complement their baked goodies.
Made with high-quality ingredients, their baked goods and specialty beverages are second to none. Whether you’re shopping, traveling, or just want a little frosting on your day, Cinnabon is the place to be.
And if you’re looking for a deal, they sometimes offer a free small coffee with the purchase of a Cinnabon Classic Roll or Caramel Pecanbon (this isn’t always available, so you might have to ask). So, next time you’re at The Island in Pigeon Forge, don’t forget to treat yourself to the sweet, cinnamon-infused delights at Cinnabon.
Sweet! at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a candy lover’s dream come true. With 2,500 square feet filled wall-to-wall with every kind of candy you could ever imagine, it’s a place that brings out the kid in everyone.
From giant oversized jawbreakers to cereal box-sized Nerds, Sweet! has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. But it’s not just about the candy. The friendly staff at Sweet! is always there to help and make your visit a delightful experience.
Walking through the doors of Sweet!, you’re greeted with the aroma of sweet sugary goodness, making you feel like you’ve just entered a life-sized game board of Candy Land. It’s a place that’s sure to bring a smile to your face, no matter your age.
Whether you’re looking to satisfy a late-night sugar craving or just want to indulge in some sweet treats, Sweet! is a must-visit during your trip to The Island in Pigeon Forge. We look forward to seeing you soon!
The Bakesale at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a delightful tribute to the classic American bake sale. This charming bakery is filled with the nostalgic aroma of childhood treats, offering a variety of hand-made, candy-dipped cookies, specialty baked goods, ooey gooey rice crispy treats, and chocolatey, dreamy s’mores.
The Bakesale is more than just a bakery; it’s a celebration of community and nostalgia. The concept of the store is rooted in the tradition of community bake sales, where everyone would ‘bake their best’ for schools, churches, families in need, and community centers.
They have been making their hand-pressed, fun-shaped, decorated treats since 1990 and are delighted to share them with visitors to The Island in Pigeon Forge. Whether you’re looking for a sweet treat to enjoy during your visit or a unique gift to take home, The Bakesale is a must-visit. As they say, “Always bake your best!”
The Fudgery at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a delightful destination for fudge lovers. With over 25 years of experience in serving some of the best fudge, The Fudgery has been perfecting their delectable fudge products since 1980, and they just keep getting better.
But The Fudgery is not just any run-of-the-mill fudge shop. Here, the fudge-making process is a show in itself, with employees singing show tunes while crafting their delicious fudge. It’s a fun and entertaining experience that adds a unique touch to your visit.
The fudge at The Fudgery is top-notch, made right in front of your eyes with no shortcuts and the best ingredients available in eastern Tennessee. They offer twelve different fudge options, from rocky road and chocolate peanut butter to maple nut and extraordinary chocolate, all available by the pound.
In addition to their famous fudge, The Fudgery also offers other savory products like their signature chocolate sauces and crunchy candy apples. So, on your next trip to The Island in Pigeon Forge, make sure to stop by The Fudgery and discover a world of fudge.
The Island Creamery
The Island Creamery at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a delightful spot for ice cream lovers. This charming ice cream shop offers a huge selection of homemade ice cream flavors, delicious smoothies, and other sweet treats that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
The Island Creamery is all about quality and flavor. They use the freshest ingredients to create their delicious ice cream, ensuring that every scoop is as tasty as the last. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate or want to try something a bit more adventurous, The Island Creamery has something for everyone.
In addition to their ice cream, The Island Creamery also offers a variety of smoothies and other sweet treats. It’s the perfect place to stop for a refreshing treat during your visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
So, next time you’re at The Island, make sure to stop by The Island Creamery and indulge in a scoop (or two) of their delicious homemade ice cream. It’s a sweet experience you won’t want to miss!
Best Places for a Full Meal
Dick’s Last Resort
Dick’s Last Resort at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a dining experience like no other. Known for its outrageous, surly, and energetic wait staff, this restaurant offers a unique blend of food and fun that’s sure to make your visit memorable.
From the moment you step into Dick’s Last Resort, you’re part of the action. The staff is known for their humor, making jokes and engaging with guests in a way that’s both entertaining and interactive. It’s a place where everyone, from rug-rats to old farts, high class to no-class, can feel like they’re temporarily breaking all the rules… and getting away with it.
The atmosphere at Dick’s Last Resort is lively and energetic, making it a great place for those who dare to enter and join in the fun. Whether you’re looking for a hearty meal or a good laugh, Dick’s Last Resort is a must-visit restaurant at The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Margaritaville at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a tropical paradise that invites guests to relax and enjoy the laid-back atmosphere. Inspired by the lyrics and philosophy of Jimmy Buffett, Margaritaville transports guests to an island destination filled with warm tropical colors, natural materials, and exposed wood.
The restaurant offers unique dining spaces, a concert stage, and multiple bars. One of the highlights is the large exterior deck overlooking the Little Pigeon River. Here, guests can enjoy outdoor dining and live music at the 5 O’Clock Somewhere Bar, complete with an oversized fire pit.
Whether you’re a fan of Jimmy Buffett or just looking for a place to unwind, Margaritaville is a great destination. With its welcoming atmosphere and delicious food, it’s one of our family’s favorite places to eat at The Island in Pigeon Forge. So, raise a glass, take a bite of paradise, and let Margaritaville transport you to the island destination of your dreams.
Mellow Mushroom at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a haven for pizza lovers. This unique, order-at-the-counter restaurant offers some of the most popular menu items from Mellow Mushroom, including their out-of-this-world, hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas.
Mellow Mushroom is more than just a pizza place; it’s a space where you can hang out and enjoy craft brews and more. Their patio is pet-friendly and is adjacent to Dude’s Daiquiri Bar, making it a great spot for groups of all ages and any occasion.
One of the highlights of Mellow Mushroom is their commitment to quality. Every pizza is hand-tossed and baked on the stone, ensuring a delicious, crispy crust every time.
Whether you’re a fan of classic pizza flavors or looking to try something new, Mellow Mushroom offers a variety of options to satisfy your pizza cravings. So, on your next visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge, make sure to stop by Mellow Mushroom for a slice of pizza heaven.
This is some of the best pizza we’ve had, and we really love that they have vegan options, as we have a son with a dairy allergy, so he can have his own pizza, too!
Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen
Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a must-visit for anyone who loves Southern-style cooking. This restaurant offers a unique family-style dining experience that feels just like home. They serve up endless portions of classic Deen family recipes, ensuring that no one leaves hungry. Paula Deen’s serves great food family style in a laid back atmosphere, like their broccoli casserole.
The menu at Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen is filled with Southern-style entrees, side dishes, and desserts. Every visitor gets to end their meal with a dessert of their choice, making it a sweet ending to a hearty meal. We can’t get enough of the ooey gooey butter cake!!
One of the things that our family loves about Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen is the atmosphere. It’s warm, welcoming, and feels like you’re dining in a family home rather than a restaurant. Our oldest son, in particular, loves coming here. It’s become a regular stop for our family during our visits to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Whether you’re a fan of Paula Deen’s cooking or just love good Southern food, Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen offers a one-of-a-kind dining experience that you’re sure to remember. Be sure to stop by the Paula Deen Store on the first floor.
Timberwood Grill at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a lodge-themed dining experience that offers a genuine taste of the mountains. Inspired by the legendary hospitality of the people who have called the mountains their home for generations, Timberwood Grill is a place where you can delight in hearty food and unique drink creations.
The atmosphere at Timberwood Grill is warm and welcoming, reminiscent of a mountain lodge. It’s a place where you can relax and enjoy a meal that’s as unique as the legendary mountain men and women of yore.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Timberwood Grill offers a dining experience that’s sure to leave a lasting impression. It’s a must-visit restaurant during your trip to The Island in Pigeon Forge. So, come on in, take a seat, and enjoy the genuine taste of the mountains at Timberwood Grill.
Best Drink Options
Bob’s Lemonade at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a refreshing stop that offers the best fresh-squeezed lemonade. What sets Bob’s Lemonade apart is their commitment to using the freshest ingredients and the most efficient equipment in the industry.
The process of making their lemonade is simple yet fascinating. They use their machines to slice a lemon into eighths, pour in their low sugar blend, add fresh water, and mix the drink together right before your eyes in Bob’s Lemonade 32 oz. cup. This process ensures that every sip of their lemonade is as fresh as possible.
Their sugar blend includes less sugar than a typical soft drink, dissolves instantly, and never gets syrupy in the beverage, making it a healthier and more refreshing option.
Bob’s Lemonade is not just a place to grab a drink; it’s an experience. Watching your lemonade being made right in front of you adds a unique touch to your visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge. It’s a must-try for anyone looking for a refreshing break from the excitement of the Island’s attractions.
Dude’s Daiquiris at The Island in Pigeon Forge is an oasis in the Smoky Mountains that offers the best frozen daiquiris this side of the Caribbean. As a mom, I appreciate that they also serve virgin drinks for the kids, making it a fun stop for the whole family (as you can see from our pic above!).
The moment you step into Dude’s Daiquiris, you’re transported to a tropical paradise. The sultry rhythm of steel drums fills the air, and you can almost feel the warm ocean breezes. It’s a place where you can relax, unwind, and enjoy the laid-back atmosphere.
In addition to their fantastic daiquiris, Dude’s Daiquiris also serves an eclectic mix of craft beers from around the globe. Their pet-friendly patio is the perfect setting to kick back and enjoy your drink. With seasonal live music from The Island stage just across the courtyard, there’s no better place to relax at The Island.
Whether you’re looking for a refreshing drink after a day of fun at The Island or a place to chill out and enjoy some live music, Dude’s Daiquiris is a great destination. We always make sure to stop by on our visits to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Fins Bar and Chill
Fins Bar & Chill at The Island in Pigeon Forge is a low-key and relaxing spot that offers a unique dining and drinking experience. Whether you’re just arriving or winding down after a day of fun, Fins Bar & Chill is the perfect place to adjust your attitude and immerse yourself in the laid-back atmosphere of the Island.
One of the highlights of Fins Bar & Chill is its location. You can chill on the patio overlooking the Little Pigeon River or cozy up by the lobby’s stone fireplace. It’s a great spot for a quick bite to eat and drinks with friends or family.
And the best part? You don’t have to be staying at the hotel to enjoy Fins Bar & Chill. They welcome all guests to come in and enjoy their offerings. So, whether you’re a local, a tourist, or a guest at the hotel, Fins Bar & Chill is a must-visit spot on your next visit to The Island in Pigeon Forge.
This also could have gone into our quick bites section, so if you want a quick bite you might want to check out Fins, too!
Margaritaville Coffee Shop, located inside the Margaritaville Island Hotel at The Island in Pigeon Forge, is the perfect place to escape the daily grind. This cozy coffee shop offers a variety of freshly brewed coffee from their signature blends, including the dark roasted “Pirate’s Gold” and the caffeine-free “License to Chill.”
In addition to their coffee offerings, they also serve rich and creamy espresso-based favorites such as flavored lattes and cappuccinos, and blended options like their decadent caramel or mocha frappes. For those who prefer non-coffee drinks, they offer rich and creamy chai tea, smoothies, and hot cocoa, as well as a variety of pre-packaged drinks.
But it’s not just about the drinks at Margaritaville Coffee Shop. They also offer a light food menu featuring classic coffee shop fare like muffins, cookies, croissants, and bagels, as well as breakfast sandwiches, fruit cups, oatmeal, and their incredible yogurt parfait.
Whether you’re starting your day or looking for a mid-afternoon pick-me-up, Margaritaville Coffee Shop is a great place to relax and enjoy a delicious drink and a light bite at The Island in Pigeon Forge.
Other Great Restaurants in the Area
Here are some other great Pigeon Forge restaurants:
- Applewood Farmhouse Restaurant
- Smoky Mountain Brewery
- Mama’s Farmhouse
- Bennett’s Pit Barbecue
- Old Mill Restaurant
- Local Goat
- Alamo Steakhouse
- Huck Finn’s Catfish
Final Thoughts on Restaurants at The Island in Pigeon Forge
The Island in Pigeon Forge offers a unique dining experience that goes beyond just good food. With top restaurants like Paula Deen’s Family Kitchen and Mellow Mushroom, it’s a place where you can enjoy a variety of options, from fried chicken and pork ribs to specialty pies and gourmet burgers.
The Island in Pigeon Forge is the perfect spot for the whole family. With its variety of dining options, entertainment, and attractions, it’s a great destination for a Smoky Mountain vacation. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, The Island offers a little bit of everything to make your visit a memorable one.
So, on your next trip to Pigeon Forge, make sure to visit The Island. Whether you’re looking for a place to enjoy a delicious meal, have some good fun, or just relax and take in the sights, The Island in Pigeon Forge has plenty to offer.
Hope to see you there!